#732) The Miracle Worker (1962)

#732) The Miracle Worker (1962)

OR “Apt Pupil”

Directed by Arthur Penn

Written by William Gibson. Based on his play, and the autobiography “The Story of My Life” by Helen Keller.

Class of 2024

The Plot: Before she was a world-famous author and disability rights advocate, Helen Keller was a child left deaf and blind after a bout of meningitis at 19 months old. By age seven, Helen (Patty Duke) lives an uncommunicative, almost feral existence with her family in 1880s Alabama. Faced with the prospect of institutionalization, Helen’s parents (Victor Jory & Inga Swenson) contact the Perkins School for the Blind, who send one of their recent graduates Anne Sullivan (Anne Bancroft) to be Helen’s teacher and governess. Nearly blind herself, Anne quickly realizes the difficulties Helen presents to her, but she is determined to teach Helen communication skills, showing her manual sign language, and strictly disciplining her bad behavior. What follows is a powerful movie about two inspirational people played by two outstanding actors.

Why It Matters: The NFR calls the film “an inspiring account of human potential and ability realized”, praising the “remarkable” performances of Anne Bancroft and Patty Duke.

But Does It Really?: Longtime readers know that I submit “The Miracle Worker” for NFR consideration every year, so I’m very happy that the film finally made the cut. Despite having never seen “Miracle Worker”, I nominate it every year as a favor to my mom, a disability rights advocate herself (and lifelong Patty Duke fan). Having finally seen it, I get the appeal. “The Miracle Worker” portrays Keller and Sullivan as real people without any false sentimentality or manipulation, thanks in large part to the compelling, committed performances of Bancroft and Duke, as well as the organic, intuitive direction of Arthur Penn. It is this unsentimental approach to the material that makes the film hold up far better than so many other movies dealing with disability and keeps the film watchable all these decades later. Thank you NFR for giving “The Miracle Worker” its rightful spot on the list and freeing up a space on my annual ballot.

Everybody Gets One: Born to an alcoholic father and clinically depressed mother, Anna Marie Duke was taken in by unscrupulous talent managers John and Ethel Ross, who pushed her into showbusiness and changed her first name to Patty to ride the success of fellow child actor Patty McCormack. In her early career, Patty Duke worked primarily in television, including as a contestant on the fixed game show “The $64,000 Question”. At age 12 she landed the role of Helen Keller in the Broadway production of “The Miracle Worker” because during her audition, a very physical scene where Anne slaps Helen, she was the only actor who slapped Anne Bancroft back. By the time Duke left the show to appear in the film adaptation, her name on the theater marquee had been moved to star billing above the title alongside Bancroft. 

Title Track: Anne Sullivan was dubbed “the miracle worker” by none other than Mark Twain, who had a friendship and correspondence with both Sullivan and Helen Keller around the turn of the century. Unlike practically every other quote attributed to Mark Twain, we have evidence that it was Twain, and not one of his more obscure contemporaries, who referred to Sullivan as a miracle worker.

Seriously, Oscars?: “The Miracle Worker” received five Oscar nominations, including Director and Adapted Screenplay. Although the film lost out in those categories to, respectively, “Lawrence of Arabia” and “To Kill a Mockingbird” (and missed out on a Best Picture nod), both Anne Bancroft and Patty Duke took home acting trophies. Bancroft was in New York on Oscar night, so her Best Actress award was accepted on her behalf by Joan Crawford (but that’s another story). Winning Best Supporting Actress at age 16, Patty Duke was the youngest competitive Oscar recipient ever until Tatum O’Neal in “Paper Moon”.

Other notes

  • “The Miracle Worker” began as a 1957 episode of “Playhouse 90” starring Teresa Wright and Patty McCormack written by William Gibson. The following year, Gibson had a hit on Broadway with his play “Two for the Seesaw”, which made a star out of its lead actress, Anne Bancroft. In the wake of that success, Gibson convinced “Seesaw” director Arthur Penn (who had also directed the TV version of “Miracle Worker”) and producer Fred Coe to work on a stage adaptation of “Miracle Worker” starring Bancroft. The play premiered on Broadway in 1959 and was another hit for Gibson, with Hollywood wanting the inevitable film version. Still hurting from the botched casting of the “Two for the Seesaw” film adaptation (with Shirley MacLaine in the Bancroft part), Gibson, Penn, and Coe insisted on Anne Bancroft playing Anne Sullivan over a bigger star like Elizabeth Taylor or Audrey Hepburn. United Artists agreed but in return gave them a smaller budget of $1.3 million (about $14 million today).
  • We open with a pre-credit scene of Helen’s parents discovering that she is blind and deaf. It’s a bit distressing, but thankfully the hysteria of this scene is tampered down for the rest of the movie. Also, thanks to one shot in the opening credits of a Christmas tree ornament, “The Miracle Worker” qualifies for my “Die Hard Not Xmas” list.
  • Normally I would devote part of this write-up to the real Helen Keller and Anne Sullivan, but I’m holding off until I’ve watched their other NFR representation: the 1954 documentary “Helen Keller in Her Story”. What I will point out is that in real life Anne Sullivan did not speak with an Irish brogue. Anne Bancroft played Sullivan with an Irish lilt to help shake off the pronounced Bronx accent she used in “Two for the Seesaw”. Despite this historical inaccuracy, practically every Anne Sullivan since Bancroft has performed the part with the brogue.
  • For anyone who only knows Anne Bancroft as Mrs. Robinson, watching her riveting performance here demonstrates her underrated range as an actor. I especially love Anne’s first scene with Helen as she tries to teach her the words “doll” and “cake”. In an almost-one take sequence, we watch Sullivan as she is simultaneously teaching and learning from Helen, calculating the best way to approach her first student. There’s a steady determination in Bancroft’s performance that propels the character throughout the movie.
  • On the one hand, the role of Helen Keller is not a supporting one; she’s a co-lead whose screentime takes up well over half the movie. On the other hand, you can’t have Patty Duke competing against her co-star at the Oscars, to say nothing of such competition as Katharine Hepburn and Bette Davis, so the Supporting category it is. Despite all this, Duke is worthy of any trophy you want to give her for this performance; somehow playing all of Helen Keller’s disability without becoming saccharine or cringe-inducing. Side Note: Helen Keller was still alive when both the stage and film versions of “The Miracle Worker” premiered, and while I don’t know what her thoughts on either of these were, she did meet Patty Duke in the spring of 1961, just before filming began.
  • In addition to the great performances by our two leads, I also enjoyed Inga Swenson as Helen’s strong-willed mother Kate. It’s nice to know that Inga Swenson’s acting capabilities went far beyond trading Germanic barbs with Robert Guillaume.
  • The most memorable scene in the film is Anne teaching Helen how to behave at the breakfast table, which quickly escalates into an extended physical altercation as Helen lashes out and Anne tries to restrain her. The 10-minute sequence contains almost no dialogue, but thanks to these two performances and some excellent staging, you know exactly what they’re both thinking as they recognize each other as an equal adversary. And shoutout to an uncredited Beah Richards as the family maid, who gets to deliver the scene’s punchline.
  • One weird thing about this movie is that while there are several scenes between Anne and Helen with minimal dialogue, the scenes with Anne and the rest of the Keller family are spoken at a quick, Sorkin-esque pace. It’s like they’re making up for lost time or something. Thankfully, the dialogue slows down for the crucial parts, but there were times where I debated putting on the subtitles.
  • Surprisingly, there were several moments in this film that made me laugh out loud. The film’s occasional comic relief never feels forced and always stems from the characters and their interactions. My favorite is Anne trying to sign “crochet” for Helen but forgetting how to spell it midway through and instead signing “sewing”. “It has a name, and sewing isn’t it.” Having once read “crocheted” aloud in school as “crotch-et-ed”, this hit hard for me.
  • The film’s climax, in which Helen finally comprehends that Anne has been teaching her the corresponding words to everything she encounters, has appeared throughout pop culture for the last 60 years, and I was afraid the occasional parody would ruin it within its proper context (I blame “Family Guy”). But I’ll be damned if I didn’t tear up when Helen finally exclaims “Waa-waa”. The moment is a natural extension of everything that came before it, and I couldn’t help but be moved by it.

Legacy

  • “The Miracle Worker” was a modest hit upon release, earning back its budget at the box office, and was a critical darling and awards season favorite. Although Arthur Penn was proud of “Miracle Worker”, in later years he expressed disappointment that his film adaptation wasn’t “cinematic” enough. Penn would rectify this with his later filmography, most famously in 1967’s “Bonnie and Clyde”.
  • “The Miracle Worker” has been remade twice for TV. The 1979 TV movie saw Patty Duke now playing Anne to Melissa Gilbert’s Helen, and a 2000 remake starred Alison Elliott as Anne and Hallie Kate Eisenberg — aka the Pepsi Girl aka Jesse Eisenberg’s younger sister – as Helen.
  • While Anne Bancroft continued to be a movie star throughout her career, she often eschewed bigger Hollywood productions in favor of better parts in lower budget movies. Five years after “The Miracle Worker”, Bancroft landed her most famous role; the middle-aged seductress Mrs. Robinson in “The Graduate”.
  • Patty Duke (or rather the Rosses) parlayed the success of “The Miracle Worker” into the TV series “The Patty Duke Show”, in which she performed the dual role of identical cousins. Following the show’s cancellation, Duke returned to film with “Valley of the Dolls”, a movie that has maintained a cult following despite how awful it is. Duke continued to act on stage and screen for the rest of her life, and devoted time to other ventures as well; serving as president of the Screen Actors Guild in the 1980s, authoring several memoirs, and advocating for people with bipolar disorder, which she was diagnosed with in 1982. In 2011, Duke returned to “The Miracle Worker” again to direct a revival of the play in Spokane, Washington.
  • And finally, I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention that Patty Duke’s son Sean Astin is represented on the NFR with two of his movies: “The Goonies” and the first “Lord of the Rings” movie. That’s all well and good, but where’s “Rudy”?

Bonus Clip: Great, now I got the “Patty Duke Show” theme song in my head. “But they’re cousins, identical cousins all the way…”

#731) KoKo’s Earth Control (1928)

#731) KoKo’s Earth Control (1928)

OR “Insane Clown Posse”

Directed by Dave Fleischer

Class of 2024

The Plot: Out from the inkwell comes Koko the Clown, as well as his companion Fritz the Dog. While walking around the world, KoKo and Fritz come across a small warehouse labeled “Control of Earth”, with several levers that can manipulate the weather, the seasons, and everything under (and including) the sun. Curiosity gets the better of our two, and what follows is the kind of abstract surrealism that was a hallmark of the Fleischer brothers.

Why It Matters: The NFR describes the Fleischer Studios’ animation as “[i]maginative, sassy, surreal and non-linear” and gives historical background on the Fleischer brothers and KoKo the Clown.

But Does It Really?: This one’s for all the animation buffs out there. Before Betty Boop and Popeye there was KoKo the Clown, and while he is all but forgotten today, the Clown – and his creators at Fleischer Studios – deserves a moment in the spotlight. As for the short itself, I found it highly inventive and very funny. An easy and enthusiastic yes for “KoKo’s Earth Control” on the Registry.

Everybody Gets One: Not his only NFR appearance, but shoutout to Max Fleischer. Born in Poland, Max and his family immigrated to New York City when Max was three years old. After studying at the Art Students League of New York, Fleischer found work as the staff cartoonist for the Brooklyn Daily Eagle. In the early 1910s, with the birth of animated short films, Fleischer began tinkering with more refined animation, inventing the earliest version of the Rotoscope, in which animation is drawn over live-action reference footage. One of these reference films was of Max’s younger brother Dave Fleischer in a clown suit (he was a part-time clown at Coney Island), which inspired their “Out of the Inkwell” series. Each cartoon in the series began with Max drawing a clown (using an ink pen and inkwell), with the clown coming to life and getting into all kinds of animated/live-action hybrid mischief. The clown went unnamed for the first five years of the “Inkwell” series, until animator Dick Huemer joined the Inkwell Studios staff and named him Ko-Ko.

Title Track: In several places online, you will see the title of this short as “Ko-Ko’s Earth Control”. KoKo’s name was spelled with a hyphen when the “Out of the Inkwell” series was distributed by The Red Seal Pictures Corporation. Following the bankruptcy of Red Seal around 1927 and a new distribution deal with Paramount, the series was renamed “The Inkwell Imps” and Ko-Ko became the legally distinct KoKo. Both the title within the film and the official NFR entry list the clown as “KoKo”.

Other notes

  • What a great concept; I’m surprised more cartoons haven’t done some variation of their characters in control of the entire world. I would also appreciate a Neil deGrasse Tyson breakdown of what would happen if you actually could control the elements in this way. Watch out guys, we got a badass clown over here.
  • There is so much creativity at play here, with the Fleischer team endlessly bending and breaking the laws of animation. The whole scene of KoKo trying to stop Fritz from pulling the switch with the big “Do Not Touch” sign is a good example, with Fritz climbing over a dashed line he created and KoKo wagging at/spanking Fritz with his giant finger.
  • But of course, the “Do Not Touch” switch is pulled, and I won’t spoil what happens after that; I had a lot of fun discovering all of this on my own, and I want to pass that experience on to you. I will warn that there’s a lot of strobe effects in this one, so those of you who are a little photosensitive may want to sit this one out.

Legacy

  • The “Inkwell Imps” series continued until 1929, when Inkwell Studios folded following some mismanagement issues. Max and Dave Fleischer formed the Fleischer Brothers studio, and eventually found success with the Betty Boop series, and later adaptations of the Popeye and Superman comics. KoKo would make appearances in the Betty Boop cartoons through 1934 (he shows up in “Snow-White”), and Fritz the Dog evolved into Betty’s love interest Bimbo.
  • KoKo and the Inkwell shorts found a new life in the 1950s thanks to television. In the early 1960s Max Fleischer reunited with his former colleague Hal Seeger to animate and produce an “Out of the Inkwell” TV show. Although 100 episodes were produced for syndication, only two are known to survive.
  • Another major Fleischer Studios innovation: A series of KoKo shorts called “Song Car-Tunes” which encouraged moviegoers to “follow the bouncing ball” and sing along. I owe a good chunk of my childhood VHS collection to the Fleischers.
  • KoKo the Clown makes a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it appearance as a background character in “Who Framed Roger Rabbit”. He’s still got it, Eddie! Sorry, wrong Fleischer cameo.

#730) Annabelle Serpentine Dance (1895)

#730) Annabelle Serpentine Dance (1895)

OR “Skirty Dancing”

Directed by William K. L. Dickson and William Heise

Class of 2024

The Plot: It’s 1895, movies don’t have plots yet. What we do have is Broadway dancer Annabelle Moore demonstrating the Serpentine dance while wearing a flowing dress, as captured by Edison’s camera. And that’s it; the film is less than a minute long, what else do you want from me?

Why It Matters: The NFR provides plenty of historical context for the film and calls it “an excellent example of what the [film] industry created to entice and enchant audiences” in the early days.

But Does It Really?: Eh, I guess. We’ve already got plenty of early Edison films on the list, but I’ll give this one a pass because I recognized it from a Chuck Workman montage, so that’s something. I could frame this in some flowery prose about the dawn of cinema, but at the end of the day, it’s just a dancing woman with a fancy dress. I’ll give “Annabelle Serpentine Dance” its due, but I’m ready to move on.

Everybody Gets One: Annabelle Whitford Moore made her professional dancing debut at age 15 at the 1893 Chicago World’s Fair. The Serpentine dance was one of many Moore filmed for Edison, all of which were quite popular with audiences. Moore would go on to join the Ziegfeld Follies as one of their original Gibson Girls and seems to have retired from performing around 1912.

Wow, That’s Dated: The Serpentine Dance was a specialty dance in the 1890s in which women wearing multilayered dresses would move them about to create a flowing pattern, often accompanied by multi-color lighting. Simple stuff, but this apparently killed in vaudeville and burlesque houses of the time. The dance was created by Loïe Fuller, a stage actor who noticed the interesting effects that occur when a stage light is shone on gauze fabric. The name “Serpentine” came from theater impresario Rudolph Aronson, allegedly coined during Fuller’s audition for him in 1891, no doubt referring to her snakelike movements during the dance. The Serpentine dance was quickly imitated by others, and Fuller’s subsequent lawsuits ruled in favor of the imitators (dance that wasn’t part of any narrative wouldn’t be protected under copyright law until 1976). By the time “Annabelle Serpentine Dance” was made, Fuller had already emigrated to Europe, settling in Paris for the rest of her life.

Other notes

  • Why this movie took two people to direct it I have no idea, but Dickson and Heise were both longtime Edison employees whose name pop up in many of these early “actualities”.
  • With Annabelle’s very flowing dress, I suspect Martha Graham would have loved this movie.
  • Despite my initial guess, the Serpentine dance does not involve running across an airport tarmac with Peter Falk and Alan Arkin yelling, “Serpentine! Serpentine!” It’s mostly an elaborate dress being moved around, but the patterns are surprisingly hypnotic.
  • This film would have been viewed in its day on Edison’s Kinetoscope, an early viewing device for movies where you would watch the film through a peephole, using a hand crank to control the speed of the film strip inside. To better replicate a real Serpentine performance, some versions of this film were color-tinted by hand. I can see how watching a woman dancing provocatively would be more popular with early moviegoers than a man sneezing.

Legacy

  • Although the NFR lists “Annabelle Serpentine Dance” as being released in 1895, some sources say it could have been released as early as August 1894. Regardless, the film was one of the first to be publicly exhibited, costing a nickel to watch (about $1.88 today). The film (as well as films in general) was a success, and helped launch moviegoing as we know it.
  • Some historians have suggested that “Annabelle Serpentine Dance” helped introduce the idea of erotica in film. Some historians have a little too much free time.
  • This may be the earliest NFR movie with a sequel. In addition to the other types of dances Annabelle Moore was filmed doing (Butterfly dance, Sun dance, etc.), she appeared in 1895’s “Annabelle Serpentine Dance, no. 2” for Edison. Moore also performed the Serpentine dance in a few films released by Edison’s rivals at the American Mutoscope Company (later known as Biograph).
  • “Annabelle Serpentine Dance” shows up every once in a while in movie history clip packages, most notably in Chuck Workman’s “100 Years at the Movies” and the 2003 documentary “Sex at 24 Frames Per Second”.
  • To the best of my knowledge, Annabelle Moore is in no way connected to that creepy doll movie “Annabelle” from a few years back. [Shudders]

The Horse’s Head 8th Anniversary: A Moment of Silents

The 8th anniversary gift is tin. Get it? ’cause it’s the Tin Man. From that movie.

Today the Horse’s Head celebrates 8 years, aka 2 terms! We’ve hit a lot of milestones along the way (and we should clear 750 movies this summer), but there’s one I wanted to acknowledge today.

It recently came to my attention that, with a few hard-to-find exceptions, I have seen every silent film on the National Film Registry. This got me thinking about conversations I’ve noticed out there in Film Discourse Land regarding where silent films stand with the movie lovers of today. While there are those who enjoy and champion this early form of film, most people steer clear of them, preferring “talkies” (these people also tend to avoid black and white movies in general, but that’s a discussion for another day). While admittedly most silent films lose their entertainment value well before they hit the century milestone, I think it’s important to keep these movies in the conversation. With this, I have challenged myself to compile a list of silent films that I could recommend to people interested in giving these flickers a shot. To help streamline things, I am focusing only on silent films on the National Film Registry, specifically narrative features and shorts (no documentaries or “actualities”, though those are great too). Most of these movies come from the late 1920s, when silent films were at their artistic peak, and most of them are comedies because physical humor tends to hold up better than two people talking via intertitles. So, without further ado:

The Horse’s Head 8th Anniversary List of Recommended NFR Silent Movies (arbitrarily categorized)

Starring Charlie Chaplin: The Kid (1921), The Gold Rush (1925), City Lights (1931)

Starring Buster Keaton: The Navigator (1924), Sherlock Jr. (1924), The Cameraman (1928)

Starring Harold Lloyd: Safety Last! (1923), The Freshman (1925), The General (1926)

Familiar IP: Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea (1916), The Mark of Zorro (1920), Peter Pan (1924), The Phantom of the Opera (1925)

Epics (three of which feature Jesus!): From the Manger to the Cross (1912), Intolerance (1916), Greed (1924), Ben-Hur: A Tale of the Christ (1925), The Big Parade (1925), Wings (1927)

Strong Female Leads: A Fool There Was (1915), The Poor Little Rich Girl (1917), Ella Cinders (1926), 7th Heaven (1927), It (1927), Sunrise (1927), Show People (1928), The Wind (1928)

Westerns: The Bargain (1914), Hell’s Hinges (1916), Wild and Woolly (1917)

Kinda Sorta Westerns: Jubilo (1919), Sky High (1922), Clash of the Wolves (1925), Hands Up! (1926)

Silent Movies with Dinosaurs!: Gertie the Dinosaur (1914), The Lost World (1925)

Comedy shorts: Mabel’s Blunder (1914), Fatty’s Tintype Tangle (1915), One Week (1920), Cops (1922), KoKo’s Earth Control (1928)

Grab Bag: Suspense (1913), The Cheat (1915), The Dragon Painter (1919), Within Our Gates (1920), The Crowd (1928)

And finally: WTF (Silent films that defy categorization): Dream of a Rarebit Fiend (1906), Princess Nicotine (1909), HE Who Gets Slapped (1924), The Fall of the House of Usher (1928), There It Is (1928)

Honorable Mention: Modern Times (1936). Not a silent movie, but filmed as such with a synchronized soundtrack of music, sound effects, and the occasional dialogue.

While we’re on the subject, I highly recommend “Hollywood” the 1980 miniseries devoted to silent filmmaking. Featuring interviews with many of the people who were there, plus narration by the comforting voice of James Mason and a wonderful score by Carl Davis. Leave it to the Brits to make the definitive documentary on American film.

Thanks as always to everyone who has stuck around these last eight years. Year Nine looks to be a good one!

Happy Viewing,

Tony

#729) The Social Network (2010)

#729) The Social Network (2010)

OR “Facebook/Off”

Directed by David Fincher

Written by Aaron Sorkin. Based on the book “The Accidental Billionaires” by Ben Mezrich.

Class of 2024

The Plot: Harvard student Mark Zuckerberg (Jesse Eisenberg), drunk and bitter after being dumped by his girlfriend Erica (Rooney Mara), creates a website that ranks the attractiveness of Harvard’s female students. The website is the talk of campus, and Zuckerberg is recruited by students Cameron & Tyler Winklevoss and Divya Narenda (Armie Hammer, Armie Hammer, and Max Minghella) to work on their idea for a Harvard website akin to the face book directories on college campuses. At the same time, Zuckerberg proposes a similar website across multiple college campuses to his friend Eduardo Saverin (Andrew Garfield), who puts down the initial seed money for “The Facebook”. Zuckerberg’s website is very popular from the start, which leads to an intellectual property theft lawsuit from the Winklevosses. As The Facebook continues to grow, Napster co-founder Sean Parker (Justin Timberlake) takes Zuckerberg under his wing, which frustrates Saverin and leads to his falling out (and subsequent lawsuit) with Zuckerberg. There’s plenty more drama and backstabbing in this very modern biopic from the dynamic duo of David Fincher and Aaron Sorkin.

Why It Matters: The NFR calls the film “a riveting examination of modern-day American business and capitalism”, praising Fincher, Sorkin, and the cast. The write-up also goes on a short tirade about society becoming isolated and a “slave to technology and the wonders it offers.” Good to know the Library of Congress has their own Ron Swanson.

But Does It Really?: “The Social Network” has been routinely hailed as a classic since its release 15 years ago, and I will not disagree with that assessment. Fincher, Sorkin, and all the film’s creatives go beyond the convoluted tech and legal aspects of this story and find the human element underneath. What could have been a very dry movie about White men sitting around and arguing is instead a visually vibrant, richly verbose movie…about White men sitting around and arguing. On top of all its creative achievements, “Social Network” has maintained its relevancy thanks to everything that has happened to Facebook since 2010, making the film seem more like “Frankenstein”, the creation of a monster that no one can control. “The Social Network” is an NFR no-brainer and a film I give my highest honor: a Damn Good Movie.

Everybody Gets One: David Fincher had been fascinated by filmmaking since watching a TV special about the making of “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid” as a child. Fincher’s first showbiz job was working as an assistant cameraman for Industrial Light and Magic (his only other NFR credit is in this capacity for “Return of the Jedi”). After making a name for himself throughout the 80’s as a TV commercial and music video director (most notably for Madonna’s “Vogue”), Fincher was selected by Fox to direct 1992’s “Alien3” which was besieged with studio tampering and met with mixed reception. Fincher’s run of highly acclaimed (and currently NFR-less) films throughout the ‘90s and ‘00s include “Seven”, “Fight Club”, and “Zodiac”. “Social Network” marks the NFR debut for screenwriter Aaron Sorkin, already famous at that point in time for penning, among other things, the play and film “A Few Good Men”, the films “Malice” and “The American President”, and the TV show “The West Wing”.

Seriously, Oscars?: A critical and commercial darling out the gate, “The Social Network” was the perceived frontrunner for the Oscars and started racking up precursor awards. By the time the Oscar nominations rolled around, “Social Network” received eight nods, trailing behind the 12 for eventual Best Picture winner “The King’s Speech”. “Social Network” did, however, score three big wins: Best Original Score (for Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross of Nine Inch Nails), Best Editing, and Best Adapted Screenplay.

Other notes

  • Ben Mezrich’s publisher started shopping around the film rights to Mezrich’s book “The Accidental Billionaires” before it was even finished. Aaron Sorkin read an incomplete draft and was attracted to the conflicting testimonies given by Zuckerberg, Saverin, and the Winklevosses. Both the book and the screenplay take their historical details from the court transcripts of the various depositions, and no one directly involved with the creation of Facebook had any input on the final film (while Eduardo Savarin did serve as a consultant on “The Accidental Billionaires”, he withdrew once his lawsuit with Zuckerberg was settled).
  • I don’t have the time to get into all the historical inaccuracies depicted in this film, suffice it to say that while all the major events are true to life, several details were changed, fabricated, or omitted for dramatic license. The biggest creative change was the “Rosebud” of Zuckerberg creating Facebook because his girlfriend dumped him. Also, it’s safe to assume that not everyone involved with Facebook’s creation tossed off rapid-fire witticisms 24/7. Sorkin has repeatedly stated that he was going for compelling storytelling over accuracy, but there’s always people who accept these kinds of films as gospel.
  • Speaking of Sorkin, man alive does this movie pack in the dialogue. The first line is spoken before the opening Columbia logo has completely faded from the screen! I know this level of speed and density of dialogue is a Sorkin trademark, but I didn’t realize how quickly you need to hop onto that moving train. I now understand why my dad had a no-talking policy when “The West Wing” was on. With its creative structuring and seemingly endless supply of clever exchanges, Sorkin’s screenplay earns its reputation as the second best screenplay with the word “Network” in the title. Shoutout to Fincher and the cast for finding the right balance that prevents the dialogue from becoming overwhelming or impenetrable, and double shout-out to the editing team of Angus Wall & Kirk Baxter for maintaining that rhythm in the final cut.
  • Everyone in this ensemble does such good work it’s hard to single anyone out. Jesse Eisenberg is great at tempering Zuckerberg’s aloofness and perceived assholic behavior; he may not be likable, but Eisenberg keeps him watchable. Andrew Garfield probably wouldn’t get cast as Eduardo Saverin today (same goes for Max Minghella as Divya Narendra), but he comes the closest to being this movie’s beating heart. And while I really don’t want to delve into anything related to Armie Hammer, I will give him kudos for playing both Winklevoss twins with zero distinction between the two. Bonus shoutout to Josh Pence, the body double for whichever Winklevoss Hammer wasn’t playing at the time.
  • The rest of this cast is a smorgasbord of character actors. I even shouted “Hey, it’s that guy!” when both Wallace Langham and Brian Palermo appeared on screen. And thanks to Rooney Mara’s brief but pivotal appearance here we now have both Mara sisters in the NFR (Kate’s in “Brokeback Mountain”). Rooney Mara has stated that the opening breakup scene took 99 takes before Fincher was satisfied, confirming Fincher’s Kubrick-like reputation for a copious number of takes.
  • Sorkin has a pretty ingenious way of unloading all the important details throughout the film: Exposition via deposition. We intercut with Zuckerberg’s various depositions with Saverin or the Winklevosses every time we need clarification of new information or story beats. These scenes also give us some of the best lines in the movie, including Zuckerberg’s claim to the Winklevosses: “If you guys were the inventors of Facebook, you’d have invented Facebook.” Also showing up in these scenes, Rashida Jones as one of Zuckerberg’s attorneys. How can you hate a movie with Ann Perkins in it? Hey, that’s two “Parks & Rec” references in one post!
  • I watched this movie with my wife, a former Facebook employee (although she was there long after the events of this movie). I’m not sure what I should and shouldn’t disclose about her thoughts on Facebook, but watching “The Social Network” with her made me understand some of the stories she has told me of her time there. Also, my wife informs me that hackathons were still a thing when she was there, though not nearly as fraternal as the one in the film.
  • Justin Timberlake isn’t the greatest actor in the world, but he does well with his part, aided by the excellent casting choice: Sean Parker is portrayed here as a mega-celebrity within the booming tech world. And if the young woman he sleeps with in his first scene looks familiar, it’s Dakota Johnson; the future “Fifty Shades” star joining her grandmother on the NFR.
  • Even though I was alive during the film’s 2003-2004 timeline, I had to be reminded of all the technology that has come about since the events of the film. Any time during my viewing I started to ask, “Why didn’t they just do x or y?” I would stop and remember that there were no smartphones or ride shares or social media to the extent we know it today (sorry, LiveJournal). As I was reminded recently, there is a short window of time between when something is new and when something has always been.
  • Apologies to every actress in this movie playing a severely underwritten female character. Take the misogynistic boys club of the tech world, add Sorkin’s history of underdeveloped roles for women, and you’ve got a movie that hasn’t even heard of the Bechdel test. I thought Eduardo’s girlfriend Christy would make it out of the movie unscathed, but she just had to turn psychotic at the end, didn’t she? Oh, and Christy’s actor is Brenda Song, who I’m told was a big Disney Channel star in the 2000s. I’ll take your word for it; I stopped watching after they phased out Vault Disney.
  • Easily this movie’s biggest flex is playing The Beatles’ “Baby You’re a Rich Man” over the end credits. That must have been half the budget right there. Also is it me or does “The Social Network” have more legal disclaimers than a typical film? I guess they took their own advice and lawyered up.

Legacy

  • “The Social Network” was released in October 2010, and while it was well-received by critics and film geeks alike, it was unsurprisingly blasted by its real-life counterparts (although Mark Zuckerberg conceded that they got his wardrobe right). In fact, the only people who seem to have enjoyed the film are Cameron & Tyler Winklevoss and then-Harvard president Larry Summers (portrayed with delicious exasperation by producer Douglas Urbanski). “Social Network” continues to rank among the best movies of the 2010s and of the 21st century (so far).
  • The inevitable “Social Network” parodies are still going strong 15 years later, with the film’s more quotable lines and overall concept getting ribbed from time to time. My favorite is still the “How It Should Have Ended” video. “It’s our time, down here!” “Did…did you just quote ‘Goonies’?”
  • “Social Network” has also spawned this weird subgenre of movies that focus on world-famous brands and their creators. Since 2010 we’ve had “The Founder” (McDonald’s), “Air” (Air Jordan), and two movies about Steve Jobs and Apple, one of which was written by Aaron Sorkin (the good one).
  • David Fincher’s immediate follow-up to “The Social Network” was an American remake of “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo”, which helped propel Rooney Mara’s career and got Angus Wall & Kirk Baxter their second consecutive Best Editing Oscar . Fincher has also directed “Gone Girl”, “Mank”, two episodes of “House of Cards”, and Justin Timberlake’s “Suit & Tie” music video.
  • Aware of Aaron Sorkin’s directorial aspirations, David Fincher allowed Sorkin to direct one shot in “The Social Network” (he won’t disclose which one), which has led Sorkin on the path of writer/director. And if you think Sorkin took historical liberties with Facebook, wait until you see what he did to “I Love Lucy”.
  • Aaron Sorkin has expressed interest in a “Social Network” sequel focusing on the role Facebook played regarding the January 6th Capital attacks, on the proviso that David Fincher returns to direct. Maybe it’s because I lived through it, but I’m waving my “Too Soon” flag on this potential movie.
  • Oh, and Facebook now has three billion users and has gone from the hip elitist forefront of social media to the #1 website for weird uncles everywhere. It happened so gradually I didn’t even notice.