
#812) Johnny Guitar (1954)
OR “Joan on the Range”
Directed by Nicholas Ray
Written by Philip Yordan and Ben Maddow. Based on the novel by Roy Chanslor.
Class of 2008
The Plot: On the outskirts of an Arizona town in the Old West, Johnny Guitar (Sterling Hayden) enters a saloon, having been sent for by the saloon’s owner, Vienna (Joan Crawford). Shortly thereafter, Vienna is confronted about her connection to the Dancin’ Kid (Scott Brady) and his gang, who have been accused of murdering the brother of Vienna’s longtime rival Emma Small (Mercedes McCambridge). With the prospect of Vienna’s saloon being closed down, Johnny agrees to stay and protect Vienna. But this is just the tip of the iceberg as plenty of secrets will be revealed in this Western that doesn’t play by anyone’s rules.
Why It Matters: The NFR calls the film “one of the stranger, kinkier Westerns of all time” with “enough symbolism to keep a psychiatrist occupied for years”. An essay by “the dean of classic film distributors” Michael Schlesinger digs into some of that symbolism.
But Does It Really?: Unfortunately I side with most 1954 critics when I say, “What the hell was that?” I’m not a fan of Westerns to begin with, so you’d think one that subverts all the tropes would hold my interest a little more, but nope, “Johnny Guitar” is just another Western I had to muddle through for this blog. Now before I hear you cry “You just didn’t get it”, clearly this movie has enough devotees to admit it might be working on a frequency I’m just not catching. “Johnny Guitar” isn’t bad, it’s just weird, but it’s another one of those underrated Westerns that film scholars love, so it finds a deserving spot on the NFR, despite my misgivings.
Title Track: Composed by Victor Young with lyrics by Peggy Lee (who also performs the song), “Johnny Guitar” plays briefly over the end titles, which clearly wasn’t enough to get the song an Oscar nomination. Speaking of…
Seriously, Oscars?: No Oscar or precursor nominations for “Johnny Guitar”, though it did land at 9th place in the French magazine’s Cahiers du Cinéma’s annual top ten list, the first hint that this film’s appeal lays abroad.
Other notes
- The novel of “Johnny Guitar” was published in May 1953 with the dedication “To Joan Crawford”. Shortly afterwards Crawford picked up the film rights to the novel and got the film set up at Republic Pictures, one of the smaller Hollywood studios which specialized in Westerns. Crawford also brought along director Nicholas Ray after a film they were going to make for Paramount fell through. “Johnny Guitar” was Crawford’s first Western since 1930’s “Modern Moon”.
- Most of the outdoors scenes were filmed on location in and around Sedona, Arizona, which explains why several shots look like they’re at Big Thunder Mountain. Allegedly, Joan Crawford refused to participate in the Arizona shoots, so all of her close-ups were filmed in-studio against rear projection of Arizona. Speaking of the cinematography, shoutout to the Trucolor process. These landscape shots look gorgeous in the kind of color that seemed to only exist in ‘50s movies.
- I can’t quite put my finger on it, but there’s something that’s throwing me about Joan Crawford’s performance. Of her five NFR appearances, “Johnny Guitar” is the only period piece, so maybe I just don’t buy her as anything other than a modern woman? Still, Westerns were very big in the ‘50s, and Joan was always good at knowing what her audience was willing to accept her in. It’s also her only color film on the NFR (so far), so maybe I’m just not used to seeing her striking features in something other than a much more forgiving black-and-white. Vienna’s also a very unsympathetic character, which makes sense for this story, but maybe I’m just used to caring more for the likes of Mildred Pierce or Blanche Hudson.
- I feel bad for Sterling Hayden. He may be playing the title character, but this is clearly Joan’s movie. He has a few heroic moments, but at the end of the day is movie really should have been called “Vienna”. There’s even a long stretch in the middle where Johnny is absent from the action. He doesn’t even get above-the-title billing! Oh, and it’s pretty obvious that Sterling Hayden doesn’t know how to play the guitar, which you’d think would be a major prerequisite for the part
- My biggest qualm with the movie: there’s too many secrets going on at the beginning. The first big scene in the saloon features all the main characters, each with some secret that won’t be revealed until later in the movie, meaning there’s a lot of opaque dialogue happening that makes you feel like you came in the middle. Not helping matters is that once the character secrets are revealed, I didn’t care.
- Somewhat infamously, everyone hated everyone else on this shoot. Crawford didn’t like Mercedes McCambridge (she wanted Claire Trevor to play Emma) and their rivalry soured production for everyone else. Crawford also didn’t get along with Sterling Hayden, and the feeling was more than mutual, with Hayden stating later that there wasn’t enough money in the world to get him to work with Crawford again, adding “And I like money.”
- Speaking of McCambridge, I liked her performance in this, mainly because it was unapologetically campy. She plays Emma with scenery-chewing gusto, making no effort to hide her desire for vengeance against Vienna. Also, as mentioned in many an essay about the film, you can definitely read a lesbian subtext into the Vienna/Emma dynamic. Ultimately this movie is about their relationship.
- As with any Western, there’s a plethora of familiar faces. There’s Ward Bond in his umpteenth NFR appearance leading the posse. The Dancin’ Kid’s gang consists of a pre-fame Ernest Borgnine, plus Royal Dano aka Robot Lincoln (hey that’s two Disneyland references in one post!). And one of Vienna’s loyal employees is John Carradine, who gets slightly more to do with his screen time here than he did in “The Court Jester”.
- Several references are made throughout the film to Albuquerque, New Mexico, but everyone pronounces it “al-ba-kirk”. Only three syllables? Not Al-ba-kirk-ee? Or even the Bugs Bunny sanctioned Al-ba-koik-ee?
- Man, I really don’t have much else to say about “Johnny Guitar”. To reiterate, I don’t think it’s a bad movie, it just didn’t hold my interest in the way I hoped it would. But hey, there’s over 900 movies on this list, I’m not going to enjoy all of them. As “Johnny Guitar” reached its inevitable showdown conclusion, all I could think as I was watching was, “What the hell was that?”
Legacy
- Although “Johnny Guitar” was a modest box office hit upon release, critics at the time hated it. The film fared much better in Europe, where it was championed by the likes of Jean-Luc Godard and François Truffaut. In subsequent years, “Johnny Guitar” has gotten a critical reevaluation, leading to more universal praise and its eventual spot on the NFR.
- Roy Chanslor wrote another western novel that would get turned into a movie: “The Ballad of Cat Ballou”.
- Among the filmmakers inspired by “Johnny Guitar” is Pedro Almodóvar, who included the film during a pivotal scene in “Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown”.
- During my viewing I wondered if the film was ever a play at some point. Turns out it wasn’t just a play, it was a musical! A musical adaptation of “Johnny Guitar” played Off-Broadway in 2004, and according to the aforementioned Schlesinger essay played up the implied lesbian subtext between Vienna and Emma to the hilt.
- And of course, electric guitarist Johnny “Guitar” Watson got his stage name after seeing this movie.



